James's working notes from Western Civ class

Table of Contents

Aristotle

Books

  • PoeticsAristotle, Poetics
    Poetics
    Summary
    Aristotle introduced poetry (not just verse, but including a story) as a form of imitation, of which different forms are the various arts. He touched on the basic history of poetry and its different kinds. He focused primarily on tragedy, and talked about the various parts of a story. He also discussed what makes for a good plot, and then walked his readers through a plot from start to finish, showing them how to construct a good one. Aristotle spent a considerable time on dic...
  • Nicomachean EthicsAristotle, Nichomachean Ethics
    Nichomachean Ethics
    Summary
    Books I, II, III
    Aristotle begins by saying that everything humans do is for the purpose of one good or another, some of which are higher or better than others. The science or study of what is good is called politics. That good is determined to be happiness, and he concludes that for happiness to be the final good, it must be self-sufficient and an end in itself. Aristotle goes on to talk about moral virtue, that it is a state of character and that it must be a mea...
  • CategoriesAristotle, Categories
    Aristotle, Categories
  • among many others

Aristotle's Paradigm (Middle Ages bkgrd)

  • Matter is eternal and exists w/o forms
  • Forms only exist with matter
  • No sensations, no imagination, no intellect w/o forms, phantasms, or species in the mind
  • Impressions on a passive mind
    • impressions are the things we see, sense
  • Active intellect perceives passive intellect
  • We know nothing about a body or its qualities, but as far as we have sensations which resemble those qualities.
  • Our sensations are the impressions which sensible objects make upon the mind. (Sense PerceptionSense Perception
    Sense Perception

    You can be good at sensing w/o being able to explain how.
    You can be skilled in using your senses & have them still make mistakes sometimes
    )
    • Like seal on wax
    • Impression is the image or form of the soul, without matter in it.
    • Impressions must resemble the things from which they are taken
    • Every sensation is the image or form of some sensible qualities of the object
  • Aristotle assumes that bodies and qualities of bodies exist. He infers the nature of sensation.

Four Causes

originative sources (with the example of a chair)

  1. Material - stuff it's made of (boards)
  2. Formal - pattern, form, plan (blueprint, schematic)
  3. Final - purpose, τέλος (desire to sit)
  4. Efficient - steps by which it comes into being (hammering, sawing)

Two Types of Philosophy

  • Practical Philosophy (moral virtues / dispositions, practice in affairs)
    • goal is to become more moral
  • Theoretical Philosophy (devoted to intellectual matters, [matter, form, motion])
    • goal is to find more knowledge
    • types of study (theology & physics are guess-work; math brings truth):
      • theology: invisible motionless deity, separated from perceptible reality, can only be imagined
      • mathematics: form + motion, shape, number; with or w/o senses, attribute of everything
      • physics: material, motion, qualities, sub-lunar, corruptible, senses, mortal

Pathway to Knowledge

Sense -> Intuition of form -> First principles -> Math -> Scientific Knowledge (Demonstrable)